Obama is by far the stupidest candidate (yes, even stupider that Hillary), so why should I care what he says about anything?

These low-IQ black preachers who pass themselves off as "rock stars" make me want to puke!

Translation of hillbilly troll trash dumbshit:

"I'm what you'd call a low class, inbred, white trash idiot. I hate it when I see an intelligent, upwardly mobile, Black man. I especially hate it when that Black man is about to get a job I feel I should get just by virtue of me being white. I mean this is America, right. If George Bush can be president, there is no reason in the World a moron like me shouldn’t be president.

“Oh, and by the way, when the Black boys at my high school stomped me on the head, much the same way they did the other whiteboy in Jena, it had no lasting effects on me. I say that because Obama looks like one of the Black guys who stomped on me. But my hatred for him is not personal, it is more race related than anything else.”

Yours truly,
One Idiot Redneck

Obama is an old-fashioned diversity pimp with a preacher's knack for bullshit.

He has no new ideas; he's a mediocrity.

And, yes, George Bush is a moron--but how does that change my opinion of Obama?

Obama is an old-fashioned diversity pimp with a preacher's knack for bullshit.

He has no new ideas; he's a mediocrity.

And, yes, George Bush is a moron--but how does that change my opinion of Obama?

Obama is an old-fashioned diversity pimp with a preacher's knack for bullshit.

He has no new ideas; he's a mediocrity.

And, yes, George Bush is a moron--but how does that change my opinion of Obama?

Mr Fungi;

A small test for you;

2,4,6,8,... what's next?

Mr Fungi;

Please answer the above question and then we can deal with your IQ fetish once and for all!

24 681

[numerals a la AMA]

24 681

[numerals a la AMA]

well

34.....
the nth number (in this case 5)

n^4 -10*n^3 + 35*n^2 -48n +24 = 34

the answer could also be

.... 10

Hopefully that helps you think a bit deeper about what IQ tests really test!

re Obama

I don't give a damn about IQ; I care about talent, and I just don't think Obama is talented. There are 3 candidates I respect: 1) the senator from Delaware who has no chance of being elected; 2) Giuliani--call him whatever you want, but he's a natural manager; 3) Bloomberg--as a Jew, will never get elected.

Quite frankly, the presidency has become a joke. The most talented would never even think of running (can you imagine trying to convince Steve Jobs to run for president? He'd laugh in your face.).

Does everyone know that the "genius" Hillary failed her bar exam? How much do you want to bet that she was gender-normed into Yale Law?

re Obama

I don't give a damn about IQ; I care about talent, and I just don't think Obama is talented. There are 3 candidates I respect: 1) the senator from Delaware who has no chance of being elected; 2) Giuliani--call him whatever you want, but he's a natural manager; 3) Bloomberg--as a Jew, will never get elected.

Quite frankly, the presidency has become a joke. The most talented would never even think of running (can you imagine trying to convince Steve Jobs to run for president? He'd laugh in your face.).

Does everyone know that the "genius" Hillary failed her bar exam? How much do you want to bet that she was gender-normed into Yale Law?

"Does everyone know that the "genius" Hillary failed her bar exam? How much do you want to bet that she was gender-normed into Yale Law?"

Who gives a crap about one standardized test?

Hell, Stevie Jobs didn't even finish college; Does anybody give a sh*t? No!

Truth of the matter is that before "affirmative action" nobody, I repeat NOBODY, cared if high achievers had previously dropped out of college or took a couple of times to pass a standardized test.

Why should only white men be afforded the privilege of having their minor setbacks overlooked?

I've too often seen this prevailing double standard and it is perplexing considering that white men for centuries had such a head start in education as far as not having to deal with competition from 50% of the population! So now, anybody else (read women and minorities) who achieves is seen with a suspect eye. THE NERVE!!!!!

And Fungus, by what measure are you using to label Obama and Hillary stupid, exactly? The low IQ comment was baseless, as usual.

re Hillbama's stupidity

Bottom line: both think the government is the answer to all social ills. I can't think of anything stupider than the "audacity of hope" and "it takes a village to raise a child"

And, of course, they are both downright liars. Try listening to their BS about the causes of "disparities."

My question to you: Would you hire either Obama or Hillary to manage your 4-star brothel?

I would not.

Anyone think we'll see Hillary or Obama address the salient points raised in this article? (That was a rhetorical question.)

SEARCH SITE

Advanced Search






NEW BOOK:
The Immigration Solution:
A Better Plan Than Today's
by Steven Malanga, Heather Mac Donald, Victor Davis Hanson


Are Cops Racist? How the War Against the Police Harms Black Americans.
by Heather Mac Donald


EMAIL | PRINT | RESPOND | DIGG THIS | VIEW SELECTED RESPONSES
Heather Mac Donald
The Jena Dodge
Demonstrators and the media avoid the stubborn truths of black social breakdown.
24 September 2007

Let’s assume the worst about Jena, Louisiana, and the charges of attempted murder brought against five black youths for beating a white student unconscious last December: that the district attorney’s indictments were motivated by rank racism, and that the racial tensions in this town of 3,000 are exclusively the product of white animus against blacks. Does it follow that this latest object of frenzy on the media’s racism beat is emblematic of America’s judicial system or the state of race relations today?

That is certainly what the ever-expanding army of racial victimologists and their media enablers would have you believe. Since the Jena story became international news last week, the media, the advocates, and pandering politicians have erupted in an outpouring of seeming joy at the alleged proof—after so much diligent trolling for evidence—that America remains a racist country. Senator Hillary Clinton told the NAACP: “This case reminds us that the scales of justice are seriously out of balance when it comes to charging, sentencing, and punishing African Americans.” Senator Christopher Dodd declared that Jena reveals that “de facto segregation”—in the spirit of Jim Crow—“is still very real” in many parts of America. Britain’s Observer announced that Jena shows “how lightly sleep the demons of racial prejudice in America’s deep south.” The New York Times has designated Jena “a high profile arena in the debate on racial bias in the judicial system”—a debate that perhaps not everyone was aware that we were having. J. Richard Cohen, president of the Southern Poverty Law Center, said: “I think a lot of people recognize that the criminal justice system grinds down people of color every day. Oftentimes, it’s nameless, it’s faceless. . . . People see Jena as the tip of the iceberg and ask: What lies beneath?” Needless to say, the Reverends Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton have vowed with Biblical thunder to avenge the Jena innocents and force America to own up to its mistreatment of blacks.

Unquestionably, the attempted murder charges (which were later dropped for four of the defendants, while a sixth assailant was booked as a juvenile) merit scrutiny. If the indictment in fact resulted from discrimination, then the prosecutor would deserve the strongest punishment—debarment at the very least and harsh federal penalties for civil rights violations. And the incident that seems to have led to the group assault on the white student—three students’ hanging of nooses from a school tree where white teens congregated—was a despicable provocation. If adults in Jena condoned such incendiary behavior, then these grown-up enablers truly are throwbacks to a vicious American past, and all citizens should revile them. There is evidence, however, that such adolescent cruelty is not official policy. The school principal told a black student who had inquired about the segregated tree that he could sit there or anywhere else he pleased.

But even if the worst possible interpretation of these events is merited, the massive international attention to this tiny town would seem vastly disproportionate to the cause, unless Jena stands for a more widespread problem. The idea behind the protests and the politicians’ exploitation of them is that just as these five youths were overcharged, the hundreds of thousands of blacks in prison are also the victims of systemic abuse. But for institutional racism, the black prison population would be much smaller.

This is an old complaint, for which no proof has ever been offered, Hillary Clinton’s irresponsible statement notwithstanding. The usual evidence in support of the charge that the criminal laws discriminate against blacks is the far stiffer sentences for selling and possessing crack cocaine compared with powdered cocaine. But that colorblind sentencing regimen, which dates from 1986, was a heartfelt effort to protect the overwhelmingly black victims of crack, not to penalize them. Black liberals such as Congressman Charles Rangel were loudest in sounding the alarm about the effects of crack in the black ghetto. Not even the most deluded racial apologists have ever explicitly suggested that racial bias motivated Congress’s efforts to combat a drug that results in much higher rates of violence among dealers and users, quicker and more onerous addiction, and more emergency room visits than its powdered cousin.

The reason that the black incarceration rate is the highest in the country is that blacks have the highest crime rate—by a long shot. Don’t trust the police, prosecutors, or judges to give a fair picture of black crime? Then go where the bodies are. Los Angeles is representative. In the first seven months of 2007, blacks in Los Angeles were murdered at a rate ten times that of whites and Asians. Who’s killing them? It’s not whites and Asians. While a minor proportion of the assailants of blacks are Hispanic, the vast majority are black themselves. Nationally, blacks commit murder at about eight times the frequency of whites. In New York, any given violent crime is 13 times more likely to have been committed by a black person than by a white person, according to the reports of victims and witnesses. Though they are only 24 percent of the city’s population, blacks committed 68.5 percent of all murders, rapes, robberies, and assaults in New York last year. Whites, who make up 34.5 percent of New Yorkers, committed only 5.3 percent of violent crimes. These ratios are similar across the country. In Los Angeles, blacks committed 41 percent of all robberies in 2001, according to victims’ descriptions, though they constitute only 11 percent of the city’s population. Robbery victims identified whites, who make up 30 percent of the Los Angeles population, just 4 percent of the time.

When attacking the justice system, racial agitators work mightily to change the subject from violence to drugs, using their flimsy argument that crack cocaine penalties are too high. But the vast preponderance of prisoners are in the pen for violence and property crime. In 2003, 52 percent of inmates in state prisons were serving time for violent offenses, 21 percent for property offenses, and only 20 percent for drug offenses. To be sure, black incarceration rates are off the charts. Black men were 41 percent of the more than 2 million men in federal, state, and local prisons at midyear 2006. At the end of 2005, there were 3,145 prison inmates per 100,000 black males in the United States, compared with 1,244 inmates per 100,000 Hispanic males and 471 inmates per 100,000 white males. Is that because violent and property crime is overpenalized, as race advocates sometimes argue? No. Despite the advocates’ constant complaints about three-strikes laws, the criminal justice system actually underpenalizes crime because of inadequate prison space. Prosecutors cut deals to lessen sentences; sheriffs overseeing local jails regularly devise new schemes for dumping offenders back on the street to make room for the next batch. And in any case, even if penalties for particular offenses were too draconian, the punishments affect all offenders the same.

No one in the Jena stampede dares whisper a word about black crime, because it undercuts the portrait of a victimized race. You can listen to every protest across the country glorifying the “Jena Six” and you will never hear an acknowledgement of the massive social breakdown that is the black crime rate: no mention of the violence in inner-city schools that black students commit overwhelmingly; no mention of the rising homicides in midsize cities that young black males commit when they feel “disrespected.” It is not racism that is putting black men in jail; it’s their own behavior.

What about the broader significance of Jena? Again, assuming for the sake of argument that this minuscule Louisiana town seethes with the crudest bigotry, held uniquely by whites against integration-seeking blacks, is Jena’s supposed state of affairs a microcosm of America? To the contrary: there is not a single elite institution in the country that is not twisting itself into knots in favor of African-Americans. Every minimally selective college is desperately seeking to enroll more black students. Boosting black enrollment requires drastically lowering a college’s admissions criteria to overcome the intractable 200-point SAT gap between black and white high school students, but every college institutes such double standards for the sake of “diversity.” Any black student who graduates from high school with decent grades and respectable SATs will leapfrog over thousands of more qualified white and Asian students right into the Ivy League. Blacks are also the hottest commodity for exclusive private schools that serve as training grounds for the Ivies. Andover, Exeter, Choate, and every other fancy prep and day school practice the same double standards in their eagerness to admit African-American students. After college, law schools, business schools, medical schools, engineering schools, and others accept black students whose test scores would disqualify them if they were white or Asian.

The preferences continue into the professions. Wall Street law firms annually flagellate themselves over their lack of proportional representation of black associates and partners, even though the number of blacks who graduate from law school with grades and bar-exam scores comparable with the firms’ white hires is negligible. The lack of comparably qualified black candidates does not stop the law partnerships from hiring black associates, though. Corporations have saddled themselves with massive “diversity” bureaucracies whose only function is to justify hiring and promoting less qualified African-Americans and Hispanics. Newspapers, TV stations, and advertisers put enormous pressure on themselves to have blacks on their staffs and to show black faces to the world.

In short, the opportunities for blacks to roar ahead in the economy if they stay out of trouble, study, and apply themselves are legion, but the numbers taking advantage of these opportunities are not. California’s state superintendent of public instruction broke a longstanding taboo this August by pointing out that middle-class black students in the state score worse on math and English than poor white and Asian students—a disparity that applies across the country. The usual poverty excuse for black underachievement does not hold up.

The Jena protesters will go home in denial of these truths. In fact, the purpose of such mass celebrations—and that is indeed what they are—is to make sure that attention stays far away from the actual problems holding blacks back. Astronomical rates of black criminality are not the only topic that the Jena rallies have obscured. No one wallowing in Jena promotion has had the courage to speak about an even more important crisis, the breakdown of marriage. The nearly 70 percent national illegitimacy rate for blacks—a number that can approach 90 percent in inner cities—is a cataclysm. Its consequences go far beyond the harm to individual black children—especially boys—who grow up without fathers. The real poison of the marriage crisis is the message it sends to young men about personal responsibility. The first duty in civil society is toward one’s own children; everything else is built around it. But when boys are raised without any expectations that they will have to support their children and marry the mother of those children, they fail to learn the most basic lesson about responsibility. They also are freed from the civilizing force of the marriage requirement, which pressures young men to become attractive mates. With enough support, individuals can overcome the moral perils of the illegitimacy culture, but given the prevalence of black crime and disaffiliation from the working world, it’s clear that not enough young men are finding ways to do so.

The race industry will try to keep Jena in the media and political spotlight for as long as possible, and to reinforce the notion that this episode exemplifies blacks’ situation in America. But if there were many other instances of (arguable) overcharging for black crime, we would have heard about them by now. The orgy of Jena coverage will not just fail to improve the lagging performance of blacks; it will impede such improvement by strengthening the victim mentality. Both whites and blacks are complicit in this sabotage. These ecstatic festivals of racism-bashing are a crippling ritual in the codependency between absolution-seeking whites and angry blacks, a phenomenon that Shelby Steele has powerfully analyzed. The demonstrators exhibit a palpable desire for the moral clarity of the civil rights era, as do the reporters, who have covered their every utterance. “This is the first time something like this has happened for our generation,” one student told the New York Times. “You always heard about it from history books and relatives. This is a chance to experience it for ourselves.”

He’s right; there has been nothing like Selma or Montgomery for the current generation, because much of America has accomplished almost an about-face on race since the 1950s. The current martyrs to American bigotry are a far cry from Rosa Parks. Like the “Jena Six,” they tend to have committed acts of violence or other crimes for which they are allegedly being excessively punished. Think of the six high school hooligans from Decatur, Illinois, whom Jesse Jackson tried to beatify in 1999 when their schools expelled them for a violent stadium fight; their backgrounds included robbery, trespassing, truancy, and failing whole school years. We are only belatedly learning that Mychal Bell, the sole member of the “Jena Six” to have been prosecuted for knocking out and kicking Justin Barker, has a previous arrest record that includes battery and property damage. Barker’s injuries led to $14,000 in medical bills, according to a lawyer.

The Jena situation is undoubtedly a bit more complex than the tale that the press has woven of hate-filled whites and peace-loving blacks. But even if it were not, the catharsis that this morality play has offered to its participants is spurious. The real tragedy is the dysfunctional culture that holds back too many blacks from seizing the many opportunities open to them.

EMAIL | PRINT | RESPOND | DIGG THIS | VIEW SELECTED RESPONSES

Search by Topic: ------------------------------- Advocacy Groups Affirmative Action Architecture Arts & Literature Barriers to Building Bilingual Education Business and Economy Charter Schools Children & Family Compassionate Conservatism Crime Culture and Society Drugs Economic Development Education Energy Environment Ethnicity Faith Based Programs Feminism Foreign Affairs Government Reform Ground Zero Healthcare Higher Education History Homeland Security Homelessness Housing & Redevelopment Immigration Islam Law Enforcement Legal Issues Love & Sex Media Mental Illness Monuments National Politics New York City New York State NYC Economy NYC Politics NYC Schools NYPD NYS Politics Obituaries Other Cities Parks Philanthropy Policing Political Correctness Politics Poverty Prisons Quality of Life Race Race & Ethnicity Race Relations Regulation Religion School Curriculum & Programs School Discipline School Finance & Management School Vouchers Schools & Ethnicity Special Education Subsidized Housing Taxes and Budget Teachers Unions Tech and Environment Technology Telecommunications Terrorism Transportation Underclass Unions Urban Issues War on Terror Welfare WTC
Search by Issue: ------------------------------- 2007 Spring v17 n2 2007 Winter v17 n1 2006 Autumn v16 n4 2006 Summer v16 n3 2006 Spring v16 n2 2006 Winter v16 n1 2005 Autumn v15 n4 2005 Summer v15 n3 2005 Spring v15 n2 2005 Winter v15 n1 2004 Autumn v14 n4 2004 Summer v14 n3 2004 Spring v14 n2 2004 Winter v14 n1 2003 Autumn v13 n4 2003 Summer v13 n3 2003 Spring v13 n2 2003 Winter v13 n1 2002 Autumn v12 n4 2002 Summer v12 n3 2002 Spring v12 n2 2002 Winter v12 n1 2001 Autumn v11 n4 2001 Summer v11 n3 2001 Spring v11 n2 2001 Winter v11 n1 2000 Autumn v10 n4 2000 Summer v10 n3 2000 Spring v10 n2 2000 Winter v10 n1 1999 Autumn v9 n4 1999 Summer v9 n3 1999 Spring v9 n2 1999 Winter v9 n1 1998 Autumn v8 n4 1998 Summer v8 n3 1998 Spring v8 n2 1998 Winter v8 n1 1997 Autumn v7 n4 1997 Summer v7 n3 1997 Spring v7 n2 1997 Winter v7 n1 1996 Autumn v6 n4 1996 Summer v6 n3 1996 Spring v6 n2 1996 Winter v6 n1 1995 Autumn v5 n4 1995 Summer v5 n3 1995 Spring v5 n2 1995 Winter v5 n1 1994 Autumn v4 n4 1994 Summer v4 n3 1994 Spring v4 n2 1994 Winter v4 n1 1993 Autumn v3 n4 1993 Summer v3 n3 1993 Spring v3 n2 1993 Winter v3 n1 1992 Autumn v2 n4 1992 Summer v2 n3 1992 Spring v2 n2 1992 Winter v2 n1 1991 Autumn v1 n5 1991 Summer v1 n4 1991 Spring v1 n3 1991 Winter v1 n2 1990 Autumn v1 n1
Search by Author: ------------------------------- Abraham, Spencer Ackerman, Ray Adam, Robert Allen, Brooke Allen, Charlotte Anderson, Brian C. Andrews, William Anemone, Louis Antongiavanni, Nicholas Arkin, Marc Atamian, Christopher Austin, D. Andrew Badillo, Herman Barnes, John A. Bawer, Bruce Begun, Martin Bender, Bruce Bendiner, Robert Beran, Michael Knox Berger, Stephen Bertsch, Jason Beston, Paul Betanzos, Amalia Bidinotto, Robert James Biederman, Daniel Biller, Aaron Blohm, Marilyn Boot, Max Bork, Charles Bovard, James Boyles, Denis Bratton, William J. Brooke-Hitchins, Harley Brookhiser, Richard Brooks, Arthur C. Brooks, David Brunie, Charles H. Bruno, Joseph L. Butcher, Jonathan Cadou, Bettie Cantwell, Mary Carlson, Tucker Carr, Matthew Carroll, Thomas W. Carroll, Vincent Castro, David Chavez, Linda Chubb, John Clavel, Matthew Coats, Dan Cohn, Jules Coles, Anthony P. Colt, Suzanne K. Colvin, Geoffrey Conner, Roger Cooper, Bruce Copland, James R. Cornuelle, Richard Costikyan, Edward N. Cove, Peter Cowin, Andrew J. Craig, Edward John Craig, Stephen G. Crouch, Stanley Crovitz, L. Gordon Cunningham, Mark Daley, Janet Dalrymple, Theodore deFiebre, Conrad Demaree, Allan T. DeRussy, Candace Dhondy, Farrukh Diamond, Joe Dickens, Charles DiIulio, Jr., John J. Dockery, Matthew J. Domanico, Raymond Donohue, William A. Dreher, Rod Editors, The Ehrenhalt, Alan Eimicke, William Eisland, June Elwell, John Epstein, Marc Ernst, Katherine Etzioni, Amitai Fallon, Beth Feser, Edward Fielden, Edward Filer, Randall K. Fischel, William A. Fitzgerald, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Zelda Fliegel, Seymour Foreman, Jonathan Franck, Michael Franck Lohsen McCrery, Frigand, Sid Fuchs, Ester R. Fund, John Gallagher, Maggie Garaufis, Nicholas Garibaldi, Gerry Gelernter, David Gelinas, Nicole Genn, Colman George, Robert P. Georgia, Paul Gilder, Richard Glaeser, Edward L. Glastris, Paul Glazer, Nathan Glick, Adam P. Golden, Howard Goldsmith, Stephen Gratzer, David Gray, Christopher Greenberg, Keith Elliot Greene, Jay P. Grinker, William Gruen, Michael S. Gunther, Charles Gutmann, Stephanie Hanson, Victor Davis Harnett, Patrick J. Harris, Lee Hawes, Elizabeth Hazlett, Thomas W. Heinemann, H. Erich Hellman, Peter Hirschfeld, Thomas P. Hirsh, Dennis Hitchens, Christopher Hollander, Anne Hollander, Paul Holley, Marc Hood, Clifton Horowitz, Michael Howard, Paul Howard, Philip K. Huber, Peter W. Husock, Howard Hymowitz, Kay S. Iannone, Carol Isikoff, Erin Jacobs, James B. Jacoby, Jeff Jacoby, Tamar Janko, Edmund Judd, Peter Kagann, Stephen Kamarck, Elaine Kanfer, Stefan Kaplan, Jonathan Kaplowitz, Joshua Kasinitz, Philip Kass, Jody Kasson, John F. Kaus, Mickey Kean, Patricia Keating, Raymond Keegan, Lisa Graham Kekes, John Kelling, George L. Kerik, Bernard B. Kimball, Roger King, Marjorie King, Nicholas Kisida, Brian Klavan, Andrew Klein, Amy Klein, Joe Klein, Maury Kontorovich, E. V. Kotkin, Joel Kramer, Hilton Kramer, Rita Krikorian, Mark Kudlow, Lawrence Kurtz, Stanley LaGrasse, Carol W. Lane, Eric Lejeune, Anthony Leo, John Lindsey, Lawrence B. Lochhead, Carolyn Lohsen, Arthur London, Herbert Lowe, David Garrard Lukacs, John Mac Donald, Heather Macchiarola, Frank J. MacGuire, James Mack, Dana Magnet, Julia Magnet, Myron Mahoney, Daniel J. Mahoney, Margaret Main, Thomas Malanga, Steven Manno, Bruno McCarthy, Jane McCaughey, Elizabeth McConville, Daniel J. McCrery, James McGowan, William McMahon, E. J. McWhorter, John H. Mead, Lawrence Messinger, Ruth Meyer, Peter Mildner, Gerard Miller, Judith Mills, Mark P. Miniter, Richard Moe, Terry Mone, Lawrence Monroe, Lorraine Moore, Stephen Moore, Steven E. Morgan, Richard E. Morris, Charles Morrison, James Morrone, Francis Moss, Mitchell L. Moynihan, Daniel Patrick Murdoch, Rupert Murdock, Deroy Murphy, Peter Murphy, Philip Murray, Charles Murray, Douglas Murray, Iain Naipaul, Sir V.S. Nathan, Richard Nelson, Diana Netzer, Dick Nordlinger, Pia Norquist, John O. Norton, Rob Noyelle, Thierry O'Connell, Paul E. O'Neill, Dave M. Olsen, Henry Olson, Walter K. Pagan, Antonio Page, Charles Palubinsky, Beth Z. Pawel, Michael Pennoyer, Peter Philips, Steven Pipes, Daniel Plotinsky, Benjamin A. Podhoretz, Norman Polan, Steven M. Poller, Nidra Presser, Stephen B. Randolph, Allen Ravitch, Diane Raymond, Ray Rector, Robert Reed, Henry Hope Regan, Ned Reinharz, Peter Reisinger, Anne Lenhard Rendell, Hon. Edward G. Reppetto, Thomas Reynolds, Glenn Ridley, Jane Riebling, Mark Rieder, Jonathan Rivlin, Alice M. Robb, John Robinson, Matthew Rose, Jonathan Rose, Joseph B. Rosen, Gary Rosenberg, Jan Rosenberg, Matt Rubenstein, Edwin Ryan, Richard Rybczynski, Witold Saffran, Dennis Safir, Howard Sager, Ryan Sahm, Charles Upton Salins, Peter D. Sammons, Richard Sandler, Ross Satel, Sally Savas, E. S. Schiff, Arthur Schiffren, Lisa Schiller, Erin Schoenbrod, David Schundler, Bret Schwartz, Joel Schwarz, Mary Elizabeth Scruton, Roger Scully, Vincent Segal, Lydia G. Seligman, Daniel Shalit, Wendy Shaw, Peter Shectman, Paul Shefter, Martin Siegel, Fred Siegel, Harry Silber, Kenneth Silver, Harris Simpson, John Skerry, Peter Sleeper, Jim Smith, Bradley A. Smith, Dennis Smith, Shepard Smith, Thomas Gordon Smith, Van Sniderman, Paul M. Solomon, Barbara Probst Sorman, Guy Sousa, William H. Spigner, Archie Sprung, Laurence Starr, Roger Stein, Harry Stern, Sol Stern, William J. Steyn, Mark Stoddart, Alexander Straub, Frank Sylvester, Kathleen Tallmer, Matthew Taranto, James Taylor, Flagg Teachout, Terry Thernstrom, Abigail Thierer, Adam D. Thomas, Clarence Tinsley, Ed Torrey, E. Fuller Trachtenberg, Leo Trollope, Frances Trujillo, Manuel Tubbs, David L. Tucker, William Unz, Ron K. Vacco, Dennis C. Vander Weele, Maribeth Vigilante, Richard Vigilante, Susan Vincent, Norah Viteritti, Dr. Joseph Vitullo-Martin, Julia Wagner, David Wagner Jr., Robert F. Waldinger, Roger Ward, Robert Watkin, David Weeks, Steve Weinberger, Jerry Wells, David Wharton, Edith Whitehead, Barbara Dafoe Will, George F. Williams, Terry Wilson, James Q. Winkler, Franz K. Winnick, Louis Wriston, Walter B. Wylde, Kathryn Yarbrough, Jean M. Zdanowicz, Mary T. Zremski, Jerry Zuckerman, Mortimer
More by Heather Mac Donald:
The Abduction of Opera
Cop Killers in High Places
Animating Ourselves
More . . .
This story was cited in:
RealClearPolitics
Michelle Malkin
FrontPageMag

Home | About City Journal | City Journal Books | Archives | Links
Contact Us | Subscribe Print | Subscribe Online | RSS | Advertise

CONTACT INFO:

editorial: (212) 599-7000 • fax: (212) 599-0371 • subscriptions: (800) 562-1973

Copyright The Manhattan Institute

homeabout CJCJ booksarchiveslinkssubscribecontact usrssadvertiseCJ editorsPrintEye on the NewsReviewsIn the NewsCJ printCJ online

Anyone think we'll see Hillary or Obama address the salient points raised in this article? (That was a rhetorical question.)

SEARCH SITE

Advanced Search






NEW BOOK:
The Immigration Solution:
A Better Plan Than Today's
by Steven Malanga, Heather Mac Donald, Victor Davis Hanson


Are Cops Racist? How the War Against the Police Harms Black Americans.
by Heather Mac Donald


EMAIL | PRINT | RESPOND | DIGG THIS | VIEW SELECTED RESPONSES
Heather Mac Donald
The Jena Dodge
Demonstrators and the media avoid the stubborn truths of black social breakdown.
24 September 2007

Let’s assume the worst about Jena, Louisiana, and the charges of attempted murder brought against five black youths for beating a white student unconscious last December: that the district attorney’s indictments were motivated by rank racism, and that the racial tensions in this town of 3,000 are exclusively the product of white animus against blacks. Does it follow that this latest object of frenzy on the media’s racism beat is emblematic of America’s judicial system or the state of race relations today?

That is certainly what the ever-expanding army of racial victimologists and their media enablers would have you believe. Since the Jena story became international news last week, the media, the advocates, and pandering politicians have erupted in an outpouring of seeming joy at the alleged proof—after so much diligent trolling for evidence—that America remains a racist country. Senator Hillary Clinton told the NAACP: “This case reminds us that the scales of justice are seriously out of balance when it comes to charging, sentencing, and punishing African Americans.” Senator Christopher Dodd declared that Jena reveals that “de facto segregation”—in the spirit of Jim Crow—“is still very real” in many parts of America. Britain’s Observer announced that Jena shows “how lightly sleep the demons of racial prejudice in America’s deep south.” The New York Times has designated Jena “a high profile arena in the debate on racial bias in the judicial system”—a debate that perhaps not everyone was aware that we were having. J. Richard Cohen, president of the Southern Poverty Law Center, said: “I think a lot of people recognize that the criminal justice system grinds down people of color every day. Oftentimes, it’s nameless, it’s faceless. . . . People see Jena as the tip of the iceberg and ask: What lies beneath?” Needless to say, the Reverends Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton have vowed with Biblical thunder to avenge the Jena innocents and force America to own up to its mistreatment of blacks.

Unquestionably, the attempted murder charges (which were later dropped for four of the defendants, while a sixth assailant was booked as a juvenile) merit scrutiny. If the indictment in fact resulted from discrimination, then the prosecutor would deserve the strongest punishment—debarment at the very least and harsh federal penalties for civil rights violations. And the incident that seems to have led to the group assault on the white student—three students’ hanging of nooses from a school tree where white teens congregated—was a despicable provocation. If adults in Jena condoned such incendiary behavior, then these grown-up enablers truly are throwbacks to a vicious American past, and all citizens should revile them. There is evidence, however, that such adolescent cruelty is not official policy. The school principal told a black student who had inquired about the segregated tree that he could sit there or anywhere else he pleased.

But even if the worst possible interpretation of these events is merited, the massive international attention to this tiny town would seem vastly disproportionate to the cause, unless Jena stands for a more widespread problem. The idea behind the protests and the politicians’ exploitation of them is that just as these five youths were overcharged, the hundreds of thousands of blacks in prison are also the victims of systemic abuse. But for institutional racism, the black prison population would be much smaller.

This is an old complaint, for which no proof has ever been offered, Hillary Clinton’s irresponsible statement notwithstanding. The usual evidence in support of the charge that the criminal laws discriminate against blacks is the far stiffer sentences for selling and possessing crack cocaine compared with powdered cocaine. But that colorblind sentencing regimen, which dates from 1986, was a heartfelt effort to protect the overwhelmingly black victims of crack, not to penalize them. Black liberals such as Congressman Charles Rangel were loudest in sounding the alarm about the effects of crack in the black ghetto. Not even the most deluded racial apologists have ever explicitly suggested that racial bias motivated Congress’s efforts to combat a drug that results in much higher rates of violence among dealers and users, quicker and more onerous addiction, and more emergency room visits than its powdered cousin.

The reason that the black incarceration rate is the highest in the country is that blacks have the highest crime rate—by a long shot. Don’t trust the police, prosecutors, or judges to give a fair picture of black crime? Then go where the bodies are. Los Angeles is representative. In the first seven months of 2007, blacks in Los Angeles were murdered at a rate ten times that of whites and Asians. Who’s killing them? It’s not whites and Asians. While a minor proportion of the assailants of blacks are Hispanic, the vast majority are black themselves. Nationally, blacks commit murder at about eight times the frequency of whites. In New York, any given violent crime is 13 times more likely to have been committed by a black person than by a white person, according to the reports of victims and witnesses. Though they are only 24 percent of the city’s population, blacks committed 68.5 percent of all murders, rapes, robberies, and assaults in New York last year. Whites, who make up 34.5 percent of New Yorkers, committed only 5.3 percent of violent crimes. These ratios are similar across the country. In Los Angeles, blacks committed 41 percent of all robberies in 2001, according to victims’ descriptions, though they constitute only 11 percent of the city’s population. Robbery victims identified whites, who make up 30 percent of the Los Angeles population, just 4 percent of the time.

When attacking the justice system, racial agitators work mightily to change the subject from violence to drugs, using their flimsy argument that crack cocaine penalties are too high. But the vast preponderance of prisoners are in the pen for violence and property crime. In 2003, 52 percent of inmates in state prisons were serving time for violent offenses, 21 percent for property offenses, and only 20 percent for drug offenses. To be sure, black incarceration rates are off the charts. Black men were 41 percent of the more than 2 million men in federal, state, and local prisons at midyear 2006. At the end of 2005, there were 3,145 prison inmates per 100,000 black males in the United States, compared with 1,244 inmates per 100,000 Hispanic males and 471 inmates per 100,000 white males. Is that because violent and property crime is overpenalized, as race advocates sometimes argue? No. Despite the advocates’ constant complaints about three-strikes laws, the criminal justice system actually underpenalizes crime because of inadequate prison space. Prosecutors cut deals to lessen sentences; sheriffs overseeing local jails regularly devise new schemes for dumping offenders back on the street to make room for the next batch. And in any case, even if penalties for particular offenses were too draconian, the punishments affect all offenders the same.

No one in the Jena stampede dares whisper a word about black crime, because it undercuts the portrait of a victimized race. You can listen to every protest across the country glorifying the “Jena Six” and you will never hear an acknowledgement of the massive social breakdown that is the black crime rate: no mention of the violence in inner-city schools that black students commit overwhelmingly; no mention of the rising homicides in midsize cities that young black males commit when they feel “disrespected.” It is not racism that is putting black men in jail; it’s their own behavior.

What about the broader significance of Jena? Again, assuming for the sake of argument that this minuscule Louisiana town seethes with the crudest bigotry, held uniquely by whites against integration-seeking blacks, is Jena’s supposed state of affairs a microcosm of America? To the contrary: there is not a single elite institution in the country that is not twisting itself into knots in favor of African-Americans. Every minimally selective college is desperately seeking to enroll more black students. Boosting black enrollment requires drastically lowering a college’s admissions criteria to overcome the intractable 200-point SAT gap between black and white high school students, but every college institutes such double standards for the sake of “diversity.” Any black student who graduates from high school with decent grades and respectable SATs will leapfrog over thousands of more qualified white and Asian students right into the Ivy League. Blacks are also the hottest commodity for exclusive private schools that serve as training grounds for the Ivies. Andover, Exeter, Choate, and every other fancy prep and day school practice the same double standards in their eagerness to admit African-American students. After college, law schools, business schools, medical schools, engineering schools, and others accept black students whose test scores would disqualify them if they were white or Asian.

The preferences continue into the professions. Wall Street law firms annually flagellate themselves over their lack of proportional representation of black associates and partners, even though the number of blacks who graduate from law school with grades and bar-exam scores comparable with the firms’ white hires is negligible. The lack of comparably qualified black candidates does not stop the law partnerships from hiring black associates, though. Corporations have saddled themselves with massive “diversity” bureaucracies whose only function is to justify hiring and promoting less qualified African-Americans and Hispanics. Newspapers, TV stations, and advertisers put enormous pressure on themselves to have blacks on their staffs and to show black faces to the world.

In short, the opportunities for blacks to roar ahead in the economy if they stay out of trouble, study, and apply themselves are legion, but the numbers taking advantage of these opportunities are not. California’s state superintendent of public instruction broke a longstanding taboo this August by pointing out that middle-class black students in the state score worse on math and English than poor white and Asian students—a disparity that applies across the country. The usual poverty excuse for black underachievement does not hold up.

The Jena protesters will go home in denial of these truths. In fact, the purpose of such mass celebrations—and that is indeed what they are—is to make sure that attention stays far away from the actual problems holding blacks back. Astronomical rates of black criminality are not the only topic that the Jena rallies have obscured. No one wallowing in Jena promotion has had the courage to speak about an even more important crisis, the breakdown of marriage. The nearly 70 percent national illegitimacy rate for blacks—a number that can approach 90 percent in inner cities—is a cataclysm. Its consequences go far beyond the harm to individual black children—especially boys—who grow up without fathers. The real poison of the marriage crisis is the message it sends to young men about personal responsibility. The first duty in civil society is toward one’s own children; everything else is built around it. But when boys are raised without any expectations that they will have to support their children and marry the mother of those children, they fail to learn the most basic lesson about responsibility. They also are freed from the civilizing force of the marriage requirement, which pressures young men to become attractive mates. With enough support, individuals can overcome the moral perils of the illegitimacy culture, but given the prevalence of black crime and disaffiliation from the working world, it’s clear that not enough young men are finding ways to do so.

The race industry will try to keep Jena in the media and political spotlight for as long as possible, and to reinforce the notion that this episode exemplifies blacks’ situation in America. But if there were many other instances of (arguable) overcharging for black crime, we would have heard about them by now. The orgy of Jena coverage will not just fail to improve the lagging performance of blacks; it will impede such improvement by strengthening the victim mentality. Both whites and blacks are complicit in this sabotage. These ecstatic festivals of racism-bashing are a crippling ritual in the codependency between absolution-seeking whites and angry blacks, a phenomenon that Shelby Steele has powerfully analyzed. The demonstrators exhibit a palpable desire for the moral clarity of the civil rights era, as do the reporters, who have covered their every utterance. “This is the first time something like this has happened for our generation,” one student told the New York Times. “You always heard about it from history books and relatives. This is a chance to experience it for ourselves.”

He’s right; there has been nothing like Selma or Montgomery for the current generation, because much of America has accomplished almost an about-face on race since the 1950s. The current martyrs to American bigotry are a far cry from Rosa Parks. Like the “Jena Six,” they tend to have committed acts of violence or other crimes for which they are allegedly being excessively punished. Think of the six high school hooligans from Decatur, Illinois, whom Jesse Jackson tried to beatify in 1999 when their schools expelled them for a violent stadium fight; their backgrounds included robbery, trespassing, truancy, and failing whole school years. We are only belatedly learning that Mychal Bell, the sole member of the “Jena Six” to have been prosecuted for knocking out and kicking Justin Barker, has a previous arrest record that includes battery and property damage. Barker’s injuries led to $14,000 in medical bills, according to a lawyer.

The Jena situation is undoubtedly a bit more complex than the tale that the press has woven of hate-filled whites and peace-loving blacks. But even if it were not, the catharsis that this morality play has offered to its participants is spurious. The real tragedy is the dysfunctional culture that holds back too many blacks from seizing the many opportunities open to them.

EMAIL | PRINT | RESPOND | DIGG THIS | VIEW SELECTED RESPONSES

Search by Topic: ------------------------------- Advocacy Groups Affirmative Action Architecture Arts & Literature Barriers to Building Bilingual Education Business and Economy Charter Schools Children & Family Compassionate Conservatism Crime Culture and Society Drugs Economic Development Education Energy Environment Ethnicity Faith Based Programs Feminism Foreign Affairs Government Reform Ground Zero Healthcare Higher Education History Homeland Security Homelessness Housing & Redevelopment Immigration Islam Law Enforcement Legal Issues Love & Sex Media Mental Illness Monuments National Politics New York City New York State NYC Economy NYC Politics NYC Schools NYPD NYS Politics Obituaries Other Cities Parks Philanthropy Policing Political Correctness Politics Poverty Prisons Quality of Life Race Race & Ethnicity Race Relations Regulation Religion School Curriculum & Programs School Discipline School Finance & Management School Vouchers Schools & Ethnicity Special Education Subsidized Housing Taxes and Budget Teachers Unions Tech and Environment Technology Telecommunications Terrorism Transportation Underclass Unions Urban Issues War on Terror Welfare WTC
Search by Issue: ------------------------------- 2007 Spring v17 n2 2007 Winter v17 n1 2006 Autumn v16 n4 2006 Summer v16 n3 2006 Spring v16 n2 2006 Winter v16 n1 2005 Autumn v15 n4 2005 Summer v15 n3 2005 Spring v15 n2 2005 Winter v15 n1 2004 Autumn v14 n4 2004 Summer v14 n3 2004 Spring v14 n2 2004 Winter v14 n1 2003 Autumn v13 n4 2003 Summer v13 n3 2003 Spring v13 n2 2003 Winter v13 n1 2002 Autumn v12 n4 2002 Summer v12 n3 2002 Spring v12 n2 2002 Winter v12 n1 2001 Autumn v11 n4 2001 Summer v11 n3 2001 Spring v11 n2 2001 Winter v11 n1 2000 Autumn v10 n4 2000 Summer v10 n3 2000 Spring v10 n2 2000 Winter v10 n1 1999 Autumn v9 n4 1999 Summer v9 n3 1999 Spring v9 n2 1999 Winter v9 n1 1998 Autumn v8 n4 1998 Summer v8 n3 1998 Spring v8 n2 1998 Winter v8 n1 1997 Autumn v7 n4 1997 Summer v7 n3 1997 Spring v7 n2 1997 Winter v7 n1 1996 Autumn v6 n4 1996 Summer v6 n3 1996 Spring v6 n2 1996 Winter v6 n1 1995 Autumn v5 n4 1995 Summer v5 n3 1995 Spring v5 n2 1995 Winter v5 n1 1994 Autumn v4 n4 1994 Summer v4 n3 1994 Spring v4 n2 1994 Winter v4 n1 1993 Autumn v3 n4 1993 Summer v3 n3 1993 Spring v3 n2 1993 Winter v3 n1 1992 Autumn v2 n4 1992 Summer v2 n3 1992 Spring v2 n2 1992 Winter v2 n1 1991 Autumn v1 n5 1991 Summer v1 n4 1991 Spring v1 n3 1991 Winter v1 n2 1990 Autumn v1 n1
Search by Author: ------------------------------- Abraham, Spencer Ackerman, Ray Adam, Robert Allen, Brooke Allen, Charlotte Anderson, Brian C. Andrews, William Anemone, Louis Antongiavanni, Nicholas Arkin, Marc Atamian, Christopher Austin, D. Andrew Badillo, Herman Barnes, John A. Bawer, Bruce Begun, Martin Bender, Bruce Bendiner, Robert Beran, Michael Knox Berger, Stephen Bertsch, Jason Beston, Paul Betanzos, Amalia Bidinotto, Robert James Biederman, Daniel Biller, Aaron Blohm, Marilyn Boot, Max Bork, Charles Bovard, James Boyles, Denis Bratton, William J. Brooke-Hitchins, Harley Brookhiser, Richard Brooks, Arthur C. Brooks, David Brunie, Charles H. Bruno, Joseph L. Butcher, Jonathan Cadou, Bettie Cantwell, Mary Carlson, Tucker Carr, Matthew Carroll, Thomas W. Carroll, Vincent Castro, David Chavez, Linda Chubb, John Clavel, Matthew Coats, Dan Cohn, Jules Coles, Anthony P. Colt, Suzanne K. Colvin, Geoffrey Conner, Roger Cooper, Bruce Copland, James R. Cornuelle, Richard Costikyan, Edward N. Cove, Peter Cowin, Andrew J. Craig, Edward John Craig, Stephen G. Crouch, Stanley Crovitz, L. Gordon Cunningham, Mark Daley, Janet Dalrymple, Theodore deFiebre, Conrad Demaree, Allan T. DeRussy, Candace Dhondy, Farrukh Diamond, Joe Dickens, Charles DiIulio, Jr., John J. Dockery, Matthew J. Domanico, Raymond Donohue, William A. Dreher, Rod Editors, The Ehrenhalt, Alan Eimicke, William Eisland, June Elwell, John Epstein, Marc Ernst, Katherine Etzioni, Amitai Fallon, Beth Feser, Edward Fielden, Edward Filer, Randall K. Fischel, William A. Fitzgerald, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Zelda Fliegel, Seymour Foreman, Jonathan Franck, Michael Franck Lohsen McCrery, Frigand, Sid Fuchs, Ester R. Fund, John Gallagher, Maggie Garaufis, Nicholas Garibaldi, Gerry Gelernter, David Gelinas, Nicole Genn, Colman George, Robert P. Georgia, Paul Gilder, Richard Glaeser, Edward L. Glastris, Paul Glazer, Nathan Glick, Adam P. Golden, Howard Goldsmith, Stephen Gratzer, David Gray, Christopher Greenberg, Keith Elliot Greene, Jay P. Grinker, William Gruen, Michael S. Gunther, Charles Gutmann, Stephanie Hanson, Victor Davis Harnett, Patrick J. Harris, Lee Hawes, Elizabeth Hazlett, Thomas W. Heinemann, H. Erich Hellman, Peter Hirschfeld, Thomas P. Hirsh, Dennis Hitchens, Christopher Hollander, Anne Hollander, Paul Holley, Marc Hood, Clifton Horowitz, Michael Howard, Paul Howard, Philip K. Huber, Peter W. Husock, Howard Hymowitz, Kay S. Iannone, Carol Isikoff, Erin Jacobs, James B. Jacoby, Jeff Jacoby, Tamar Janko, Edmund Judd, Peter Kagann, Stephen Kamarck, Elaine Kanfer, Stefan Kaplan, Jonathan Kaplowitz, Joshua Kasinitz, Philip Kass, Jody Kasson, John F. Kaus, Mickey Kean, Patricia Keating, Raymond Keegan, Lisa Graham Kekes, John Kelling, George L. Kerik, Bernard B. Kimball, Roger King, Marjorie King, Nicholas Kisida, Brian Klavan, Andrew Klein, Amy Klein, Joe Klein, Maury Kontorovich, E. V. Kotkin, Joel Kramer, Hilton Kramer, Rita Krikorian, Mark Kudlow, Lawrence Kurtz, Stanley LaGrasse, Carol W. Lane, Eric Lejeune, Anthony Leo, John Lindsey, Lawrence B. Lochhead, Carolyn Lohsen, Arthur London, Herbert Lowe, David Garrard Lukacs, John Mac Donald, Heather Macchiarola, Frank J. MacGuire, James Mack, Dana Magnet, Julia Magnet, Myron Mahoney, Daniel J. Mahoney, Margaret Main, Thomas Malanga, Steven Manno, Bruno McCarthy, Jane McCaughey, Elizabeth McConville, Daniel J. McCrery, James McGowan, William McMahon, E. J. McWhorter, John H. Mead, Lawrence Messinger, Ruth Meyer, Peter Mildner, Gerard Miller, Judith Mills, Mark P. Miniter, Richard Moe, Terry Mone, Lawrence Monroe, Lorraine Moore, Stephen Moore, Steven E. Morgan, Richard E. Morris, Charles Morrison, James Morrone, Francis Moss, Mitchell L. Moynihan, Daniel Patrick Murdoch, Rupert Murdock, Deroy Murphy, Peter Murphy, Philip Murray, Charles Murray, Douglas Murray, Iain Naipaul, Sir V.S. Nathan, Richard Nelson, Diana Netzer, Dick Nordlinger, Pia Norquist, John O. Norton, Rob Noyelle, Thierry O'Connell, Paul E. O'Neill, Dave M. Olsen, Henry Olson, Walter K. Pagan, Antonio Page, Charles Palubinsky, Beth Z. Pawel, Michael Pennoyer, Peter Philips, Steven Pipes, Daniel Plotinsky, Benjamin A. Podhoretz, Norman Polan, Steven M. Poller, Nidra Presser, Stephen B. Randolph, Allen Ravitch, Diane Raymond, Ray Rector, Robert Reed, Henry Hope Regan, Ned Reinharz, Peter Reisinger, Anne Lenhard Rendell, Hon. Edward G. Reppetto, Thomas Reynolds, Glenn Ridley, Jane Riebling, Mark Rieder, Jonathan Rivlin, Alice M. Robb, John Robinson, Matthew Rose, Jonathan Rose, Joseph B. Rosen, Gary Rosenberg, Jan Rosenberg, Matt Rubenstein, Edwin Ryan, Richard Rybczynski, Witold Saffran, Dennis Safir, Howard Sager, Ryan Sahm, Charles Upton Salins, Peter D. Sammons, Richard Sandler, Ross Satel, Sally Savas, E. S. Schiff, Arthur Schiffren, Lisa Schiller, Erin Schoenbrod, David Schundler, Bret Schwartz, Joel Schwarz, Mary Elizabeth Scruton, Roger Scully, Vincent Segal, Lydia G. Seligman, Daniel Shalit, Wendy Shaw, Peter Shectman, Paul Shefter, Martin Siegel, Fred Siegel, Harry Silber, Kenneth Silver, Harris Simpson, John Skerry, Peter Sleeper, Jim Smith, Bradley A. Smith, Dennis Smith, Shepard Smith, Thomas Gordon Smith, Van Sniderman, Paul M. Solomon, Barbara Probst Sorman, Guy Sousa, William H. Spigner, Archie Sprung, Laurence Starr, Roger Stein, Harry Stern, Sol Stern, William J. Steyn, Mark Stoddart, Alexander Straub, Frank Sylvester, Kathleen Tallmer, Matthew Taranto, James Taylor, Flagg Teachout, Terry Thernstrom, Abigail Thierer, Adam D. Thomas, Clarence Tinsley, Ed Torrey, E. Fuller Trachtenberg, Leo Trollope, Frances Trujillo, Manuel Tubbs, David L. Tucker, William Unz, Ron K. Vacco, Dennis C. Vander Weele, Maribeth Vigilante, Richard Vigilante, Susan Vincent, Norah Viteritti, Dr. Joseph Vitullo-Martin, Julia Wagner, David Wagner Jr., Robert F. Waldinger, Roger Ward, Robert Watkin, David Weeks, Steve Weinberger, Jerry Wells, David Wharton, Edith Whitehead, Barbara Dafoe Will, George F. Williams, Terry Wilson, James Q. Winkler, Franz K. Winnick, Louis Wriston, Walter B. Wylde, Kathryn Yarbrough, Jean M. Zdanowicz, Mary T. Zremski, Jerry Zuckerman, Mortimer
More by Heather Mac Donald:
The Abduction of Opera
Cop Killers in High Places
Animating Ourselves
More . . .
This story was cited in:
RealClearPolitics
Michelle Malkin
FrontPageMag

Home | About City Journal | City Journal Books | Archives | Links
Contact Us | Subscribe Print | Subscribe Online | RSS | Advertise

CONTACT INFO:

editorial: (212) 599-7000 • fax: (212) 599-0371 • subscriptions: (800) 562-1973

Copyright The Manhattan Institute

homeabout CJCJ booksarchiveslinkssubscribecontact usrssadvertiseCJ editorsPrintEye on the NewsReviewsIn the NewsCJ printCJ online

Well we got us a real ass Mr. Fungi. Name suits your behavior though. Couldn't even give us a link. Got to print it out to read this one.

"We black folks are facing a social breakdown, and we hate cops." Boy

Looks like Fungus has finally come out of the closet!

BT

It's Fungi, which makes me superior to a genus--or does it?

Fungi does not like closets. A nice patch of grass under a shaded tree

that's for me.

Fungi,
You sound like that black conservative fellow who dragon likes to quote; his name is john mcwhorter.

Fungus grows fine in closets - keep it moist, in the dark ...

And feed it isht.

Pretty soon, you've got saprophytic and parasitic spore-producing organisms called Funguses (or Fungi at the grocery), which may be smut.

Now... You purpose in introducing the pathetic ranting of yet another disturbed soul?

Surely, if you were, as Mwafrica suggests, the esteemed Professor McWhorter - you could offer up something more urbane than the inane bleatings of a $2, back door, Ann Coulter/Linda Chavez wannabe ho' for our civil discourse?

C'est la vie.

Mr. Fungi,

"Anyone think we'll see Hillary or Obama address the salient points raised in this article? (That was a rhetorical question.)

Maybe it shouldn't have been. (rhetorical that is)Perhaps he (Obama) can say things and be listened to that others wouldn't be able to. I don't think you can put Hillary and Obama in the same camp. The link here is a good comparison. I believe we can rightly label Hillary as patronizing. But Obama does put responsibilities on the individual, as well as the our government system.

Would you agree Obama is addressing the some of the articles concerns here?

transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0703/04/le.02.html

"We've got too many children in poverty in this country, and everybody should be ashamed. But don't tell me it doesn't have a little to do with the fact that we have got too many daddies not acting like daddies, who I think that fatherhood ends at conception. I know something about that because my father wasn't around when I was young and I struggled. Those of you who read my book know. I went through some difficult times. I know what it means when you don't have a strong male figure in the house, which is why the hardest thing about me being in politics sometimes is not being home as much as I'd like.

And I'm just blessed that I've got such a wonderful wife at home to hold things together.

But don't tell me that we can't do better by our children, that we can't take more responsibility for making sure we're instilling in them the values and the ideas that the Moses generation taught us about sacrifice and dignity and honesty and hard work and discipline and self-sacrifice.

That comes from us. We've got to transmit that to the next generation and I guess the point that I'm making is that that the civil rights movement wasn't just a fight against the oppressor, it was also a fight against the oppressor in each of us.

You know, sometimes it's easy to just point at somebody else and say, it's there their fault but oppression has a way of creeping into you, Reverend. It has a way of stunting yourself. You start telling yourself, Bishop, I can't do something. I can't read, I can't -- I can't go to college. I can't start a business. I can't run for Congress. I can't run for the presidency, people start telling you can't do something, after a while, you start believing it.

And part of what the civil rights movement was about was recognizing that we have to transform ourselves in order to transform the world. Mahatma Gandhi, the great hero of Dr. King and the person who helped create the nonviolent movement around the world, he once said that, You can't change the world if you haven't changed. If you want to change the world, the change has to happen with you first. And that is something that the greatest and most honorable of generations has taught us.

Gandhi???

The same Gandhi that fought with the repressive, savage, and racist white government of South Africa??

You are trying to portray this fool as some kind of hero to Black people??

Are you that naive? Gandhi had no respect for Black/African people. You'd better check your sources before you bring that stupid stuff to Black people.

You want Black people to honor a man that fought to keep Black people subjugated to white supremacy?

The ignorance and arrogance of white supremacy never ceases to amaze.

Scurry off little cockroach...

CrackSmasha;

I just had to respond,

African people admire Gandhi, I can't speak for the Afro-Americans. He did his part and using brains was able to rescue his country from colonial oppression.

He layed foundation to what is currently the world's largest democracy and future world power.

Now that's a man who goes down in history as a great man, perhaps not to you.

And stop calling people cockroaches it is stupid

Sorry for the typo;

Should read ....."laid foundation"....

Well before we beat on CS. He does raise a good point. Abelian have you see Deepa Mehta movies?
There is mix feeling on Ghandi stance on the caste system in India, and some say the reason for his weakness on South Africa.

Should we honor him for his battle against England - Of Course.

Nehru is really the one point out as building India's global position

Sorry about that Cracka,

I should have put quotation remarks at the end of my post, after the link I linkded to all of the rest of the post was a paste from the transcript of Obama's sermon at Selma.

I assume you were looking fora reason to call me a cockroach, (I think BBPTM used the same word) but in this case you would be directing this at Obama. That was still the paste from his transcript at Selma, again sorry about not adding the last quotation mark.

Nana;

I haven't seen the movies yet. His religion bound him, just like religion bound MalcolmX, Martin Luther King. You are right he was not perfect and about Nehr.

I detest name calling that's why I responded to Cracka Smasha the way I did.

I don’t understand, if Mr. Fungi is a white man, why he continues to come here? The rich melanin on this site attracts him, no doubt, yet he is dependably racist, sexist, and ignorant? I suspect he is having the classic psychological white inferiority battle which makes him long for contact with the rich blackness but presses upon the genetic fear that if he truly comes into us, HE WILL BECOME EXTINCT! Imagine a world without white people ~ oh glory!

I don’t understand, if Mr. Fungi is a white man, why he continues to come here? The rich melanin on this site attracts him, no doubt, yet he is dependably racist, sexist, and ignorant? I suspect he is having the classic psychological white inferiority battle which makes him long for contact with the rich blackness but presses upon the genetic fear that if he truly comes into us, HE WILL BECOME EXTINCT! Imagine a world without white people ~ oh glory!

3d,phd

I'm a white female.

Racist?
Sexist?
Ignorant?

I'll respond to each of those if you'll be so kind to cite examples from my few posts.

re 5.32pm by 3d

Professor Bracey, If a white person had written something that racist it would have been deleted immediately.

Is this a racist site?

re 5.32pm by 3d

Professor Bracey, If a white person had written something that racist it would have been deleted immediately.

Is this a racist site?

re 5.32pm by 3d

Professor Bracey, If a white person had written something that racist it would have been deleted immediately.

Is this a racist site?